Skip to content
Buy 3, get 3% off - use code ZATU3
Buy 5, get 5% off - use code ZATU5

Country/region

Language

Cart 1

Spirit Island: The Dahan's guide to Spirits - Volume 1

Spirit Island board game box featuring colourful island spirits

There are a lot of diverse Spirits in the base game of Spirit Island and its expansions. One of the strengths of Spirit Island is the asymmetry of the various Spirits, but it also means that many of them are useless or even incapable of some core tactics needed to win. Spirits generally work best when combined with others; even when playing solo, people often play as two Spirits.

The usual method of balancing the Spirits is to play a game of “Compare the Bar Charts”, picking a decent aggregate of the five power summaries (Offense, Control, Fear, Defense, and Utility) so you have a good mix with nothing missing.

The purpose of this article is to be a little more specific about each Spirit than the summary of powers. This is also not just going to be about what they are good at but more about how well they work with each other, what they contribute, and what they need from others.

A Spread of Rampant Green

A Spread of Rampant Green spirit board in Spirit Island, showing growth options, Presence tracks and innate powers

A Spread of Rampant Green is a great addition to almost any group. Your base ability to sacrifice Presence to block an area’s Build or Ravage really helps nullify a particular threat wherever you can reach. As long as you keep the island healthy, this comes at no real cost due to how often you add presence, as well as being able to reclaim lost presence. Add to this the “Overgrow In A Night” card, and you can easily spread across the board.

Probably your strongest contribution is the card “Gift Of Proliferation”. Every Spirit wants to add Presence as much as possible; it increases your power and your reach. Rampant Green can let anyone get a boost, and it only costs 1 Energy. Hand this out whenever you can, and you’ll be invited to all the best parties.

Combine this with a reliable Defend power, and Rampant Green is a great ally, if slightly energy starved. You don’t get to hit hard very often, so you do want to get help from someone with a less subtle approach.

Team player:

Lightning’s Swift Strike – Lightning can end up needing to reclaim cards nearly every turn, so you are able to really help them out by letting them still add Presence.

Thunderspeaker – Thunderspeaker needs your defence. Being able to block Ravage also blocks the Dahan attacking, but it’s better than losing a fight.

River Surges in Sunlight – River takes a while to become a menace. You can hold the fort and help them accelerate their evolution.

Not a fan:

Ocean’s Hungry Grasp

Vital Strength of the Earth

Bringer of Dreams and Nightmares

Shadows Flicker Like Flame

Everyone appreciates getting to add Presence; however, this card cycles through too slowly to change the fundamental interaction. A good defence is always appreciated, but if nobody is getting the damage in, then you’re just losing more slowly.

Lightning’s Swift Strike

Lightning’s Swift Strike spirit board in Spirit Island, showing lightning artwork, Presence tracks and Thundering Destruction power

There’s a pendulum effect in the turn structure of this game. Fast powers swing the board in your favour, the Invaders push it back, and then the slow powers either repair the damage or hammer the Invaders that have arrived.

Lightning’s Swift Strike does a remarkable job of breaking this pattern. All your slow powers can be fast, and “Lightning’s Boon” lets you turbocharge anyone else. So many slow powers are slow to balance out how powerful they are, giving the Invaders time to expand beforehand. Not any more.

Lightning is also an absolute sledgehammer against buildings; as time goes on, you can raze everything around them to the ground. You do have a fundamental weakness attacking Explorers, so you really want someone to help out there.

Team player:

A Spread of Rampant Green

Ocean’s Hungry Grasp

Thunderspeaker

Vital Strength of the Earth

River Surges in Sunlight

Shadows Flicker Like Flame

You are so good at destroying buildings that it takes the pressure off everyone else. Also, “Lightning’s Boon” is a massive momentum boost for so many Spirits’ powers and cards. This would not be enough on its own, as it’s just one card, but Lightning’s card play is so high you’re eventually reclaiming it nearly every turn. It will nearly always be available and will always be appreciated.

Not a fan:

Bringer of Dreams and Nightmares – Neither have an inherent method to deal with Explorers, so you’ll be constantly having to deal with new buildings popping up. People are a problem.

Ocean’s Hungry Grasp

Ocean’s Hungry Grasp spirit board in Spirit Island, showing wave artwork, Presence tracks and innate powers

Ocean’s Hungry Grasp is probably the second most specialised Spirit when it comes to your role. The coast is the most hazardous area in the game, spawning Explorers and eventually becoming a literal beachhead for the invasion. Ocean does a great job of locking this down and making the Invaders regret their ocean view property.

Join forces with a Spirit that can push/gather, and you can drown everything that gets too close. Unfortunately, Ocean is a bit of a T-Rex, with a devastating bite but a problematic reach. You have to be playing alongside a Spirit happy to handle everything inland if you don’t want to be boiling with impotent rage. On the plus side, where you are able to reach, you are an absolute powerhouse.

Team Player:

River Surges in Sunlight

Bringer of Dreams and Nightmares

Shadows Flicker Like Flame

All of these have decent access to push/gather, and you give them a better use for it. You turn control into destruction and can happily pummel anything nearby. Let them sweep their problems your way, and you will deal with them.

Not a fan:

A Spread of Rampant Green

Lightning’s Swift Strike

Thunderspeaker

Vital Strength of the Earth

There’s nothing wrong with what you do; it’s just that you don’t really mingle much. You handle the coast, they handle everything inland, and other than the occasional postcard, you don’t really speak to each other.

Thunderspeaker

Thunderspeaker spirit board in Spirit Island, showing character artwork, Presence tracks and innate powers

Thunderspeaker is incredibly mobile and powerful, but at the cost of extreme fragility. You can move Dahan and, more importantly, move with them, so you can quickly get to wherever you’re needed.

The problem for Thunderspeaker is that your strongest power is to enable combat between the Dahan and the Invaders, but you are punished by losing Presence whenever a Dahan dies nearby. Invaders apply damage first, so you must rely on others to defend the areas you are fighting in (or near). In return, you have probably the most reliable damage in the game as you build an army and crush the opposition.

Team Player:

A Spread of Rampant Green

Vital Strength of the Earth

Thunderspeaker is not a fan of a fair fight. You can easily destroy the Invaders as long as there is enough defence to avoid casualties, so if they look after you, you can solve all their problems.

Lightning’s Swift Strike – Lightning can handle anything you throw at it but Explorers. Or, as Thunderspeaker calls them, “target practice”. After a build, Lightning takes out the new town, and you send in a Dahan to clean up.

Not a fan:

Ocean’s Hungry Grasp

River Surges in Sunlight

Shadows Flicker Like Flame

Bringer of Dreams and Nightmares

It’s not that you won’t be welcomed by these Spirits. It’s just that without a way to keep the Dahan safe, you have to be a lot more cautious. Because of this, be prepared to have to let your ally down sometimes.

Vital Strength of the Earth

Vital Strength of the Earth spirit board in Spirit Island, showing a stone spirit, Presence tracks and Gift of Strength power

With the very low card play in the early game, what Vital Strength of the Earth needs in an ally is either a bit of speed or a lot of patience. In return you can offer a steady spread of Presence and reliable defence in multiple locations.

For a worrying amount of time you are playing just one or two cards per turn, but they really matter. Be prepared to leave others to do the fun shenanigans while you concentrate on keeping the Dahan alive and the land healthy. You won’t be in the limelight, but you’ll definitely be appreciated.

Due to your powers and theirs, Vital Strength is always happy to play with the more aggressive Spirits.

Team player:

Thunderspeaker – Thunderspeaker wants to be your best friend. Not only do you supply the defence they need, the card “Rituals of Destruction” is probably one of their favourites.

Lightning’s Swift Strike – You supply the defence, they supply the mayhem.

River Surges in Sunlight – Your job is to keep everyone alive until River gets their innate power up a level or two. Then get the popcorn.

Not a fan:

A Spread of Rampant Green

Ocean’s Hungry Grasp

Bringer of Dreams and Nightmares

Shadows Flicker Like Flame

Defence is always welcome, but without decent aggression you’re going to get swarmed.

River Surges in Sunlight

River Surges in Sunlight spirit board in Spirit Island, showing a water spirit, Presence tracks and Massive Flooding power

While not as impressive as other Spirits. Rivers Surges in Sunlight also has no real weaknesses. Great access to pushing does a good job of messing with the Invaders’ momentum, and eventually your innate power, “Massive Flooding," can take out everything but Cities in one go.

River Surges offers the ability to easily push Invaders. This helps split up groups into easily digestible chunks for others to pick over.

Team player:

Ocean’s Hungry Grasp

Thunderspeaker

Being able to push Invaders is very appreciated here. Keep throwing them to the sharks with Ocean, and split up encampments for Thunderspeaker so they can have an unfair fight.

Lightning’s Swift Strike – With Massive Flooding from the second level onwards, you are able to wipe out Explorers with ease. Lightning will appreciate this greatly.

A Spread of Rampant Green

Vital Strength of the Earth

What you give here is reliable damage, as long as they don’t mind waiting a bit. Their defensive style keeps everything ticking over until you start getting Massive Flooding into play, and after that you can mop up. Victory is slow but reliable.

Not a fan:

Bringer of Dreams and Nightmares

Shadows Flicker Like Flame

The extra damage you bring is very appreciated, but the amount of push available becomes slightly redundant. We’re not playing tennis here.

Bringer of Dreams and Nightmares

Bringer of Dreams and Nightmares spirit board in Spirit Island, showing a red-eyed nightmare spirit, Presence tracks and innate powers

Bringer of Dreams and Nightmares is so specialised it’s not even playing the same game as the others. Not only do you not destroy anything, but you never can. Chasing the Invaders around can slow down their progress, but you have almost no ability to prevent new Explorers from appearing. This juggling of threats can’t be relied on, so you really have to rely on the help of others to avoid getting surrounded by Blight.

This is the highest chance to win by Fear alone, but the chances of a Blight defeat increase as well as the island filling up. Whatever the final results, you’re probably going to have a quicker game than normal.

Team Player:

A Spread of Rampant Green

Vital Strength of the Earth

As a slow defensive player, they are not going to win by destruction. No need to worry; you’ll just scare them all off the island instead.

Ocean’s Hungry Grasp – You are constantly feeding Invaders to the Ocean. The Ocean says thank you.

Shadows Flicker Like Flame - You like Fear? Me too! Let’s make every day Halloween.

Not a fan:

Lightning’s Swift Strike

Thunderspeaker

River Surges in Sunlight

The problem here is that you’re both trying to win in completely different ways, and they barely interact with each other. The game is a race to which one succeeds, with a lower chance of either.

Shadows Flicker Like Flame

Shadows Flicker Like Flame spirit board in Spirit Island, showing a shadowy flame spirit, Presence tracks and Darkness Swallows the Unwary power

Often seen as the Spirit for players too scared to play Bringer of Dreams, Shadows Flicker Like Flame is actually a much more reliable ally. Moving and destroying Explorers really helps to keep expansion under control, and the reach of your powers is incredible. You’ll be useful in combat and can speed up a Fear win.

Team player:

Lightning’s Swift Strike – You take the buildings, I’ll take the Explorers. Let the slaughter commence.

Thunderspeaker – The ability to move Explorers so they can be picked off is always welcome, but Thunderspeaker is very interested in the card “Concealing Shadows”. It’s not perfect because you still get Blight, but dropping this on a massive battle will be very impressive. The other core cards are also appreciated.

Bringer of Dreams and Nightmares – A Fear victory is a risky bet, but at least you’re both working together for it. Your ability to mess with Explorers should at least slow the Invaders down enough to give you a better chance.

Not a fan:

A Spread of Rampant Green

Vital Strength of the Earth

Ocean’s Hungry Grasp

River Surges in Sunlight

You do get some attrition, but without an ally to apply the fast and/or heavy damage, you’re not reliably going to get enough done in time.

Zatu Review Summary

Spirit Island (Core Game)

Spirit Island (Core Game)

£63.90

£89.99

Zatu Score

90%

Rating

Artwork
star star star star star
Complexity
star star star star star
Replayability
star star star star star
Interaction
star star star star star
Component Quality
star star star star star
Kevin Hackett
Zatu Games
Write for us - Write for us -
Zatu Games

Join us today to receive exclusive discounts, get your hands on all the new releases and much more! Find out more about our blog & how to become a member of the blogging team below.

Find out more