Skip to content
Buy 3, get 3% off - use code ZATU3
Buy 5, get 5% off - use code ZATU5

Country/region

Language

Cart

Lying Pirates review

Lying Pirates: The Race for the Pirate Throne game box beside a skull, candles and golden goblets.

A Ship Full of Liars and Nobody Worth Trusting

"Four threes!"

The announcement sounds confident. The player making it has a cup full of concealed dice, and you have absolutely no idea whether they're telling the truth. You could raise the bet, call their bluff or decide that this particular pirate has finally lost the plot. The problem is that getting it wrong could cost you a member of your crew, and in Lying Pirates, a smaller crew can make the rest of your voyage considerably more difficult.

Designed by Lucas Vagner, Mikaela Hård and Misha Ahmadi, Lying Pirates takes the familiar mechanics of Liar's Dice and wraps them in a competitive race across a modular pirate map. Players bluff, bet, sail, fight over rewards and use action cards to make life miserable for their rivals. The objective is to reach the finish line first, but the journey involves considerably more than rolling dice and hoping for the best.

For a game that looks like a straightforward pirate-themed bluffing exercise, there is a surprising amount happening around the table. The real question is whether all these additions make the experience more engaging or whether the game would have been better off keeping things simple.

Liar's Dice With Something at Stake

The Betting Phase is the foundation of Lying Pirates. Each player rolls their crew dice secretly inside their bamboo cup, creating a pool of hidden information that everyone must interpret.

The first player makes a bid on the total number of a particular face value across all players' dice. So, if someone announces four threes, they are claiming that at least four dice showing three will be revealed when everyone opens their cups. The next player must raise the bid by increasing the quantity or changing the face value according to the bidding rules, or challenge the previous player by calling them a liar.

Ones are wild, which makes the calculations a little more interesting. You have some information about your own dice, but the rest is an exercise in probability, observation and reading your opponents. A conservative player might make a sensible bid based on what they can see in their own cup, while someone more adventurous might push the numbers higher and hope nobody has the courage to challenge.

Eventually, somebody has to call the bluff. The dice are revealed, the claim is checked and the losing player loses a crew die. The winner gains an advantage going into the next round, while the remaining players continue their journey through the betting and sailing sequence.

The beauty of this mechanism is that losing isn't just a momentary embarrassment. Your crew dice are an important resource, and losing them makes future betting more difficult. You are therefore balancing the immediate desire to win a round against the longer-term need to preserve your crew.

It is a familiar mechanism, but the consequences give it a useful connection to the rest of the game. A bad bet can leave you in trouble for several rounds, while a successful challenge can weaken a rival at a particularly inconvenient moment.

Sailing Into Trouble

Winning the betting contest is only part of the story. The Sail Phase is where the ships start moving across the modular map, and the game introduces a new layer of uncertainty.

The winner of the betting phase gets to lead the movement, while the outcome of the round determines which other players can advance. Gold Action Cards can also influence movement, meaning that even a player who loses the betting challenge may still have a way to make progress.

This is an important distinction. Losing the betting phase doesn't necessarily mean sitting out the entire round. A well-timed card can keep you moving, which prevents one failed challenge from completely derailing your game.

The map itself is assembled using 25 modular tiles, so the route changes between sessions. Each tile has its own event, and the rewards or penalties can influence how you approach the race. Some destinations are worth pursuing, while others are best avoided if you have a choice.

When multiple ships move forward, a Tile Battle determines who gets to activate the tile they land on. Only one tile is activated each round, so reaching a destination doesn't automatically mean you get to enjoy its benefits.

I like this distinction because it gives movement a little more meaning. You aren't simply racing to occupy spaces; you are competing for the opportunity to resolve their effects. A player might manage to move forward but still lose out on the reward, which adds another layer of competition to the journey.

The modular map also helps keep the game fresh. The changing arrangement means players cannot rely on memorising a fixed route, and the different tile effects give the race a degree of unpredictability.

The trade-off is that the board can sometimes make a player's fortunes feel heavily dependent on what happens to appear in front of them. A promising position can become less attractive when the next tile is unfavourable, and the benefits of movement are not always entirely within your control. That uncertainty is entertaining when things go your way, but less satisfying when several setbacks arrive together.

The Cards Are Where Things Get Personal

The Action Phase gives players another opportunity to influence the race, and this is where Lying Pirates moves beyond its Liar's Dice foundation.

Players can play up to two Action Cards per round: one Silver and one Gold. Gold cards can be played during the Sail Phase, and using one there means you cannot play another Gold card during the Action Phase. Cards can be played in different orders, and their effects resolve immediately.

The cards offer a mixture of attacks, defensive options, movement opportunities and ways to improve your crew. They allow players to interfere with opponents, protect themselves from trouble and occasionally turn a seemingly ordinary round into a rather unpleasant experience for someone else.

Coins provide another resource to manage. They can be spent to purchase Action Cards or reroll dice during certain phases, giving players another way to influence the outcome of a round.

I particularly like that the cards don't replace the bluffing mechanism. Instead, they give players additional ways to respond to it. You might lose a betting challenge but still find a way to move forward, or use a card to make life difficult for someone who appeared to have everything under control.

Timing matters, too. Since cards resolve immediately and their order can affect subsequent actions, players need to pay attention to what others are doing. Playing a card too early can expose your intentions, while waiting too long might mean missing the opportunity altogether.

The downside is that this additional layer takes the game away from the simplicity of Liar's Dice. Players expecting a quick bluffing game may find the cards, movement effects and tile battles a little more involved than anticipated. It isn't especially difficult once you understand the rules, but the first game can involve quite a bit of checking.

Keeping Your Crew Together

The crew dice are arguably the most important resource in Lying Pirates. They determine how much information you have during the betting phase, and losing them can make future rounds increasingly difficult.

This creates a natural feedback loop. A player who repeatedly loses challenges may find themselves with fewer dice, making it harder to support ambitious bids. Meanwhile, someone who manages their crew well has a better chance of staying competitive.

There are ways to gain dice back and improve your position, so losing crew isn't necessarily a death sentence. However, the game does have a tendency to make a bad run feel worse as it develops.

This is where the balance between risk and reward becomes important. You cannot play every betting round conservatively, because doing so may leave you struggling to keep up with the ships ahead. But you also cannot afford to treat every challenge as an opportunity to gamble with your entire crew.

I like that the dice represent something more meaningful than a simple score or resource counter. They are directly connected to the central mechanism, and losing them changes how you approach future decisions.

What I like less is how difficult it can become to recover after a particularly rough sequence. The game offers opportunities to rebuild, but a player who has lost several dice may find themselves at a disadvantage in the very system they need to win in order to recover. The tension is thematically appropriate, but it can occasionally create a frustrating cycle.

A Different Voyage Every Time

The modular map is a major contributor to replayability. With 25 tiles being arranged differently between games, the route and its opportunities change from one session to the next.

The tile effects encourage players to adapt rather than follow a fixed strategy. You might find yourself pursuing a particular route because of the rewards available, only to change direction when another player gets there first. The cards add further variation, giving players different ways to approach movement and conflict.

There are also optional Captain abilities and variants that introduce additional asymmetry. These give experienced groups more ways to customise the game, and the individual abilities can make different players approach the race in different ways.

The two-player game uses a Phantom Mode, introducing an automated third pirate into the experience. It is a thoughtful solution to the problem of having too few dice in the betting pool, although I would still lean towards playing with more people.

Four players feels like a particularly comfortable configuration. You have enough hidden dice to make the betting interesting, enough competition over the map and enough opportunities for the cards to create memorable interactions. Five or six players should appeal to groups who enjoy a noisier, more chaotic experience.

The game also benefits from the fact that everyone remains involved in the betting phase. There is no lengthy downtime while one player performs a complicated turn and everyone else waits. Even when you aren't leading the action, you are watching the bids and deciding whether someone is pushing their luck.

A Pirate's Treasure Chest

The production is a noticeable part of the game's appeal. The hand-drawn artwork by Srdjan Vidakovic gives Lying Pirates a distinctive visual identity, and the combination of bamboo cups, custom dice, coins, map tiles and ship pieces creates a satisfying table presence.

The bamboo cups are particularly nice. They give the central betting mechanism a tactile quality, and hiding your dice inside them feels much more appropriate than simply rolling behind a player screen. The custom crew dice are another important component, while the modular tiles make the map feel like a proper pirate journey rather than a generic race track.

The deluxe version adds further upgrades, including metal coins, magnetic tiles and Captain Coasters with individual abilities. These are attractive additions, although the base game already contains the core experience. I would consider the deluxe components a luxury rather than a requirement.

The overall production has a strong sense of identity. It looks like a game designed around the experience of sitting together, hiding information and trying to outwit the people across the table.

Final Thoughts

Lying Pirates is an entertaining combination of bluffing, dice management and racing. Its greatest strength is the way the Liar's Dice mechanism connects to the larger game. Losing a challenge costs you crew, winning can give you an advantage in the race, and the Action Cards ensure that the outcome is rarely settled by the dice alone.

The modular map provides variety, while the tile battles and card interactions give players plenty of opportunities to interfere with one another. It is a game that encourages table talk, accusations and the occasional spectacular failure.

However, the additional systems also make it less immediate than its central mechanism suggests. The rules take some time to absorb, the dice and tile effects can produce swings in fortune, and losing crew early can make it difficult to recover. These are meaningful limitations, particularly for players who want a pure bluffing experience.

I would recommend Lying Pirates to groups who enjoy games with direct interaction, a healthy amount of unpredictability and plenty of opportunities to call someone's bluff. It works particularly well with four or more players, where the betting phase has enough information and uncertainty to become genuinely entertaining.

It isn't a replacement for Liar's Dice, nor does it need to be. It takes that familiar foundation and gives it a competitive journey to build around. Sometimes the best way to win a pirate race is to have the strongest crew. Other times, you simply need to convince everyone that you do.

Zatu Review Summary

Lying Pirates: the Race For the Pirate Throne - Deluxe Edition

Lying Pirates: the Race For the Pirate Throne - Deluxe Edition

€105,57

€107,26
Zatu Games
Write for us - Write for us -
Zatu Games

Join us today to receive exclusive discounts, get your hands on all the new releases and much more! Find out more about our blog & how to become a member of the blogging team below.

Find out more