
When Katie and I first started getting into board games, we didn't know there was a whole hobby waiting for us. We thought Toys R Us was where you bought board games. Eventually, we graduated to Barnes & Noble, where we started discovering Catan and Carcassonne. We knew about those games mostly because that one nerdy friend owned them We just didn't realize there was an entire world of games beyond what we were used to playing
Right before lockdown, we picked up Ticket to Ride, Wingspan, and Catan: Seafarers. We quickly discovered that Catan wasn't particularly enjoyable with two players. That was an early lesson in buying something without really understanding how it played or whether it would work for our household. We love Stonemaier Games. Wingspan was our first introduction to Elizabeth Hargrave, but it wasn't love at first sight. We opened the game and sat there thinking, WHAT? How do we play this? And why did we buy it? Wingspan is a great game. We just weren't ready for that level of complexity yet. I really wish Wingspan Pocket had been available back then. It probably would have saved us a lot of time!
Finding Our Way Into the Hobby
During the pandemic, we started spending more time discovering board games. We eventually made our way to what would become our favorite board game store. Walking into a place filled with games we'd never seen before was overwhelming. A staff member noticed us looking around and recommended Tiny Towns. They were so confident we'd enjoy it that they even offered a money back guarantee. Turns out, they knew what they were talking about
Tiny Towns became a family favorite and helped us discover just how much more there was to the hobby. It also opened the door to trying games we probably wouldn't have picked up on our own. Fast forward to present day, and we had the opportunity to meet Peter McPherson at a Millennium Games learn to play event. We brought along Tiny Towns and Fit to Print to get signed, which was an awesome full circle moment. We really enjoy Peter's games, and it's always fun to meet someone whose work has found its way to our table. I can't wait to see what he'll come up with next

Coming Back to Wingspan
Don't judge, but my wife had this idea that YouTube might have tutorials that could help us figure out how to play Wingspan. Enter Watch It Played! Rodney, if you ever read this, thank you for existing. For the remainder of 2020, we exclusively purchased games that you had on your channel. If Rodney hadn't explained it, we weren't playing it
Once we finally got the hang of Wingspan, we played it a lot. A lot enough that on June 1, 2020, we bought our first expansion, Wingspan: European Expansion. Before long, we were also getting into 3D printing organizers for our games. I know the pandemic was an incredibly difficult time, and I'm not trying to put a positive spin on everything that happened. But having more time at home gave us the opportunity to really dive into this hobby, and let's just say our board game addiction was getting plenty of encouragement
Then, we discovered BoardGameGeek, started digging deeper into games, and created our Instagram account. Our approach to finding games was changing. We weren't just looking at boxes anymore. We were learning about mechanics, reading reviews, and figuring out what we enjoyed, wanted to play and learn
Wait, Who Designed That?
The first designer I remember actively following was Phil Walker Harding. Games like Silver & Gold introduced me to my favorite genre: verb and write. Once I started recognizing designer names, I found myself making connections between games I already owned and the people who created them. Take Quacks of Quedlinburg, for example. I'm a sucker for roll and writes, and I'm pretty obsessed with the Clever series. After playing Quacks multiple times, I noticed the designer's name looked familiar. Turns out, Wolfgang Warsch designed both! He also designed The Mind, another game we thoroughly enjoy

It's funny how you can enjoy several games without realizing they're all coming from the same person. Once I started making those connections, I became much more interested in seeing what else those designers had created. Sometimes, though, the connections happened much later. I only recently realized that Steffen Benndorf designed Qwixx, The Game, and Ohanami. The Game is my most played card game, and I had no idea he was behind Ohanami too. They're very different games, but there's something interesting about discovering that connection after enjoying both independently. Then there are designers like Chris Priscott. I absolutely love Zuuli, and discovering his other games has made me want to follow his work. There's just one little logistical problem: he primarily sells his games in the UK. So whenever I visit, I make a point of checking out what he has available. And when I can't wait until my next trip, well, there's always Zatu. Sorry, local game store!

Getting to Know the People Behind the Games
I've also had the privilege of getting to know some designers, including Eric Olsen. When you've had the opportunity to connect with someone behind a game you enjoy, it's interesting to see what they come up with next. I find myself paying a little more attention to their upcoming projects, even if I don't necessarily know whether the game will be a fit for us
With that said, not every designer makes games I love. For instance, Shem Phillips. I LOVE Shipwrights of the North Sea. I've played some of his other games, too, but they don't necessarily call to me in the same way. Katie, on the other hand, loves the Architects of the West Kingdom series and the North Sea games, so I'm happy to play them with her and friends. But if I were picking one for myself, I'd probably reach for something else. That's probably the best example of why following a designer doesn't mean I'll automatically want everything they make. I can love one game, appreciate another, and have absolutely no interest in adding a third to my collection
There are also a handful of designers whose names have become pretty reliable indicators that I'll at least want to investigate a game. Reiner Knizia and Jamey Stegmaier come to mind. We still find ourselves picking up their games based on the name alone, and I'm here for it
From Impulse Buying to Catch and Release
These days, my buying process looks pretty different from those early days of shopping based on box art. I spend a lot more time researching a game before deciding whether it belongs in our collection. I'll look at the designers, check BoardGameGeek, watch how to play videos, and try to figure out whether the mechanics and overall experience are something we'll actually enjoy. Part of that comes from having a collection that's already plenty big. We're trying to be more intentional about what we buy rather than accumulating games that end up sitting in shrink wrap
There's also the reviewer side of things. I receive copies of games to review, so not every game that makes it to our table is something we've purchased ourselves. That gives us the chance to try games we might not have otherwise picked up, but it also makes being thoughtful about what we keep even more important. Of course, that doesn't mean I've stopped buying games on impulse entirely. The used game section is still a dangerous place. Sometimes a game is just too good of a deal to pass up, and that's where our catch and release approach comes in. I actually wrote about this in Confessions of a Board Game Thriftaholic, where I share more about buying used games, giving them a try, and eventually sending some back out into the world
Not every game needs to become a permanent part of our collection. Sometimes we want to try something, enjoy it for a while, and eventually decide it's time to make room for something else. Wanting to play a game and wanting to own a game aren't always the same thing
So, Does the Designer Matter?
Absolutely. But probably not in the way I would have expected when I first started collecting.
I buy games because the box is pretty sometimes. I'm only human. Now I recognize designer names, look into their previous work, and get curious about what they're creating next. Following designers has become another way to discover games. It's not a guarantee that I'll love something, and it certainly doesn't mean every game they make belongs in my collection.
For me, it's about knowing a little more about the people behind the games, recognizing the connections between the games I enjoy, and having another way to find something new to bring to the table

About the Author
Coty is a board game blogger, reviewer, and accidental LEGO art collector. When she’s not testing rulebooks or trying to beat her wife at two-player games, she’s playing ice hockey. Follow her adventures on Instagram or read more at KaCo Plays





