You know that feeling when looking at an old photo, and you don't recognize what's staring back at you? That's how I feel looking at our first shelfie. When my wife and I first moved in together, we put together a board game shelf that was less of a curated collection and more of a messy archaeological dig. It was packed with the classics that survived childhood moves. Games like Rummikub, Taboo, and Cranium. Out of all of them, Rummikub is the only one that has survived. It’s the one we still pull out to play with the fam fam.
Over a decade ago, our board game world was small. We genuinely thought Toys R Us was the only place that sold them. Then we graduated to the limited selection at Barnes Noble. But then? We walked into Millennium Games
Voila! Our collection didn't just grow; it exploded. We’ve moved our first shelf several times since those early days. Five years ago, it started getting tighter. Today? That same shelf is absolutely bursting with roll and writes and party games
As our collection grew, we became more selective. If you’ve seen my Confessions of a Board Game Thriftaholic, you know I’ve bought over 100 used games, but I’ve sold and gifted almost as many right back into the ecosystem. We eventually realized that board games aren't just boxes to be stored; they are the environment we create together. We were tired of having a random shelfie tucked in a corner of the house. We wanted a destination
Sooooo, we decided to finish our basement. It started as a terrifyingly blank canvas. No shelves, no games, just potential. We didn't want to just buy furniture; we wanted to build something. My wife did the planning, and I provided the heavy lifting and the encouraging commentary on whether the boards were leveled
The finished product is everything we wanted. But a funny thing happened once we had all this space: we realized we didn’t want to fill every inch with boxes
Because we’ve gotten so much stricter on keeping games we actually play, the unit has become more of a decorative statement. It’s a mix of our favorite titles and things that just make the room feel like us. Lately, that means Legos and plants that don’t die. Legos have that same detailed, tactile feel I love in a game component, and the fake greens provide life without the guilt of negligent plant-homicide. We still have a few Kallaxes for the overflow, but this unit is the heart of our gaming room
We haven't quite finished the bottom section yet. The doors and the trim are still in the works. That lower area won't actually hold games. Instead, it’s for the game-adjacent essentials: blankets for cozy sessions, puzzles, and the ever important laminator. Things that support the hobby without being the hobby itself. Our home evolved with our collection. It started with a shelf of childhood nostalgia and became a custom space for the life we’ve built over the last ten years. Board games are great, but the memories you make in the room you make for them? That’s the real win!
About the author:
Coty is a board game blogger, reviewer, and accidental LEGO art collector. When she’s not testing rulebooks or trying to beat her wife at two-player games, she’s playing ice hockey. Follow her adventures on Instagram or read more at KaCo Plays.
